I’m just sitting here frustrated because I’m wanting my family to move away from messaging me over SMS (they mainly use iOS), but they refuse to download any extra apps. But Google’s RCS really doesn’t look like a solution either since it mainly just seems to be a way of enforcing Android as an ecosystem, and they don’t even make RCS available for 3rd party apps to use either.
The primary form of text communication in Australia is sms. I do a bit of regional travel in Australia and after adopting “chat features” (RCS) in the Google sms app I started having critical messages failing to go through (without notifying me) because of poor (data) reception and it wasn’t falling back to sms.
I love the features RCS brings to messaging and would love to use it, but it’s just not reliable without an uninterrupted data connection.
- Google creates a cross platform iMessage competitor
- Only nerds know about it because Google didn’t market it
- Google gets upset that no one is using their cross platform iMessage competitor
- Google cancels their cross platform iMessage competitor
- repeat
For me, Allo was the last straw. Hangouts before it. Google Voice before it. Google talk before it.
fool me once, shame on – shame on you. Fool me – you can’t get fooled again
Either Apple takes its head out of its ass, or it’s always going to be fragmented, RCS or otherwise.
The rest of the world uses WhatsApp or something else that’s popular in their country. I know it’s not helpful in your case but you guys really need to get over SMS if you want something better and the reason why is because the EU is about enforce all those chat app giants to be able to talk to eachother so if I use Viber but you ube WhatsApp we can still talk anyway, which is pretty fucking cool, but it won’t matter for you if you keep using SMS.
Ever since they switched to RCS, I constantly have to manually resend things via SMS just for the messages to actually send. IDK what the main differences are, but the fact that it doesn’t even work 80% of the time is why I hate RCS.
Huh, I hadn’t heard about any of this. I guess that’s because I use Google Voice, and none of the features going into the Messages app have made it over to the Voice app.
Got rid of my GV # after ~10 years w/ it so that I could use RCS. Not a vast difference tbh but feels a lot more modern
Since when is rcs dead? More and more of the people I use texting with come “online” all the time.
Weird takes.
This (year old) article is funnier in hindsight/context of AP’s own article.
We already have a lot of next messaging platforms already that don’t rely on phone numbers and ones which do (like Whatsapp).
Also, in this case it’s really Apple’s fault
The ONLY way to fix the wider world of messaging is mandatory adversarial interoperability.
No matter how clever your new standard is, it will not work.
Adversarial interoperability – even if it is gated to only be required of sufficiently large businesses/platforms – will be the end of all this bullshit once implemented. Messaging should be about the people and the messages, not the platforms.
I’m just sitting here frustrated because I’m wanting my family to move away from messaging me over SMS (they mainly use iOS), but they refuse to download any extra apps.
Weird family. Pretty much all my family and friends happily installed WhatsApp except for the odd ancient mad auntie and that’s probably for the best because it’d get racist quick.
The main issue would be trying to wean them off WhatsApp onto another system (XMPP? Matrix?).
Hah, meanwhile, the younger ones use Telegram here because the weird old people are on WhatsApp and can’t stop sending boomer messages. xD
Now I’m wondering if that’s what’s happening with me and I’m the one sending Boomer messages…
- Do you like to send greetings and images like these on special days, or even just the mornings: https://www.asiaone.com/digital/have-some-boomer-friendly-hygiene-tips-share-family-group-chats-courtesy-lifebuoy
- Do you feel compelled to spread news on alarming incidents without verification? Especially related to health and safety? Like someone said that eating blueberries can lead to increased cancaer risk, so OMG my kids and their friends like blueberry muffins, I need to spread the word!
- Do you feel a need to report on anything that has happened to you, or people around you (especially bad things that happened to people around you)?
If you answer yes to them, congrats, you’re a boomer!
They’d annoy me, sounds like I can stick with Gen X for now…
I just ignore those who send such messages. Eventually they stop sending.
deleted by creator
Bad take. The problem isn’t RCS, it’s Apple.
Seriously. We can’t just let Apple off the hook for their anti-competitive walled garden.
Users should continue to demand that they support the more open standard.
I think it’s complex and the problem have been many things. When Apple pitched an open version of iMessage to the carriers long ago they refused because the didn’t like the E2EE. They were surprised when Apple later introduced a proprietary version (and subsequently discovered it was a competitive advantage).
Now there’s a Client-server encrypted version of RCS in GSMA but the E2EE version is Google’s and running on Google’s service. It was only recently that two carriers in the US agreed to use Google’s messaging app for interoperability but is E2EE in GSMA?
Interoperability have been a problem as at one point carriers weren’t even interoperable while using Universal Profile (I think they are now). Apple surely wont use it unless forced (it makes business sense not to) but between GSMA Universal Profile (which Apple would have to use) and Google’s much better version based on the Signal protocol the current situation is also a mess.
cut those people out of your lives forever!
sorry mom and dad, kick the iPads or I’m not answering the phone anymore
That’s an extreme measure for people who socialize with others in a healthy manner.
Gross
we need fediverse of instant messaging, where big boys like whatsapp etc are forced to become interoperable with the likes of signal etc
What kind of crap article is this? It’s paragraphs and paragraphs of words saying that we should just accept the previous status-quo of a bajillion different apps. The headline might as well be “RCS sucks, just give up.” which is such a defeatist way to say absolutely nothing.
AI. Sponsored by shills. Welcome to the future
