i was gonna say 6 at the first pic, but the second pic makes me think it’s an 8! nice taper, nice size, i like how the little nubs add visual interest.

Pros:

• from the look, great length for a sword
• looks straight enough
• the thickness doesn’t seem too thin so might be okay to throw

Cons:

• Aerodynamics need work
• adding a point increases the coolness factor by a substantial percentage
• not thick/long enough so it can’t serve as a walking stick imo

In conclusion, solid 8/10. Good stick

At least an 8. It could be longer but a solid stick.

9/10

Can we see the pup who carries that stick while walking awkwardly because it is too long?

8/10. I would definitely find a use for this stick on an adventure.

Id say 8/10

You gotta tie a wiffle ball on top to make a badass wizard staff. Then it will be 10/10.

We should ban stick pics on this platform.

It’s a goodun but I’d nip off those sharp bits up at the top for ease of handling

I’d give it a 7. Pretty straight, but no good handles to use it as a gun or cross guard to use it as a sword. It’d work as a lightsaber though. But the thickness and heft is nice.

Nice stick

A solid 8.

I’d give it a 7. Would be higher if it was longer.

It feels good to see my hunch rating of 8 is right on par with the consensus here.

For me it’s got great shape and is a good size, the uncanny straightness of it is really cool, but serves to limit it’s potential ceiling for ratings. It can’t specialize in anything to push it to the top of the ratings.

deleted by creator