You must log in or register to comment.
When I say “everything” I mean that I don’t have a specific list of genres I listen to. I can listen to any kind of music as long as it’s to my liking and it does not matter if it’s dead metal or k-pop or classical… Every genre has a lot of stuff I like and a lot of stuff I hate.
Hard agree. Like I’m not gonna say no if someone says “can I put on some death metal” because I’ve found surprise favorites in every genre I’ve listened to. Doesn’t mean I’m going to like that particular song or artist, though.
I’m a “I listen to everything except Country and Ska” friend.
*modern pop country. Waylon, Willie, Loretta, Dolly and the like are alright with me.
I’m the opposite. I can stand some of the modern pop country, but I can’t stand whiny old country.
You can’t relate to your pick up not starting?
That’s modern pop country
Which with the self driving* cybertruck has been upgraded to “my truck left me…”
As for music, some of that bland mainstream pop…
Legit, I am still waiting for the country song where the girl runs off with his cybertruck…
Nothing whiny about Johnny Cash stealing car parts from Cadillac
Touche!
So you’d listen to https://carlstone.bandcamp.com/track/sumiya?
I think this is music, it even has a proper beat, although some weird backkick 7/33 or something. By the other posters description I imagined something way more extreme haha
I thought it would be Woodpecker No.1 or something in that vein.
Reminds me of listening to my non-buffering CD player on the bus ride to school.
I’d argue that nobody could call this music in the way that normal people understand what music is. It feels like an experiment in sound more than anything.
A common definition I just looked up on “Music” is:
vocal, instrumental, or mechanical sounds having rhythm, melody, or harmony
There is none of those in what you’ve linked. No rhythm, no melody, and nothing harmonious.
So no, it doesn’t fit the definition of Music; therefore, I probably wouldn’t listen to it. I did sample other of the artists tracks like Wat Dong Moon Lek, Himalaya, Ahirya, and all of his pieces are like this. They aren’t really music.
No rhythm? It’s complicated, changing, but to my ears the whole thing is an exercise in rhythm.
It’s interesting to me how different people interpret what music means to them. To me I would call this music as it fits the definition of melody
A pleasing succession or arrangement of sounds.
Of course that is subjective to everyone. To me Carl Stone’s tracks do have a beautiful melody. To others they feel chaotic, and to some they feel minimalist.
A melody (from Greek μελῳδία (melōidía) ‘singing, chanting’),[1] also tune, voice or line, is a linear succession of musical tones that the listener perceives as a single entity.
The problem here is with the compositions absolute randomness of nature. It sounds exactly like what was being produced by computers, before some of the more advanced audio models came about. It doesn’t sound like any kind of single entity, and it would be nearly impossible for anyone to distinguish it from random sounds.
In a cacophony of random elements, I couldn’t hear this song. But I could hear most others without issue. It doesn’t meet the sniff test.
The melodies existing in most European music written before the 20th century, and popular music throughout the 20th century, featured “fixed and easily discernible frequency patterns”, recurring “events, often periodic, at all structural levels” and “recurrence of durations and patterns of durations”.
All of which this lacks. It simply doesn’t meet the definition of music. Though I bet it’s a great source of inspiration for those experimenting with music themselves. Honestly, I had to load it up in YouTube to make sure the web-based music player wasn’t glitching out or something; it was bad enough as “music” that I thought something was wrong with the computer.
But I’ll just kindly agree to disagree - if you enjoy it, great. I just wouldn’t even consider this music and would immediately ask for music to be put on.
I’ve got a death metal style Less Than Jake t-shirt to confuse you
I love death metal tbh.
So it would work, you’d leave bemused and confused wondering what that band was lol
There are some fine young lads in checkered flat caps and suspenders who would like to have a word with you.
Hoyt Axton - The Devil
I mean, even for a country song that was just kinda…I dunno. It feels like with some changes it could be good, but there’s this weird part where the wording feels like it skips a beat because he couldn’t get the beat to synchronize with the cadence of the words. I’ll listen to a lot of country, but there’s still gonna just be bad songs.
Interesting. I’m not a big country fan, but that song is nearly perfect to me.
Around 1:03, he completely breaks cadence and the whole rhythm of the song breaks. I don’t know how this could be considered good. Regardless of it being country or not.
That’s music for you. I think that transition is excellent.
I still don’t listen to much country, but Orville Peck has been a gateway drug. Something about gay cowboy ballads does it for me.
I’m more into trash than death, since the majority of the latter is guttural, which I just can’t stand.
You mean…thrash? Or is there a new genre with Oscar the grouch
Ops, my mistake. I blame the english language
I’m no expert on the subgenres, but that sounds accurate for me too.
So I recently subjected my partner to SKÀLD (viking folk chants) and she unexpectedly loved them
But Billy o’ Tea is pretty fun.
I don’t want to associate with anyone that doesn’t like sea shanties anyway.
The only thing I really miss from reddit are the niche communitites, and sea shanties is one of them :(
TIL pirate metal exists. Thanks.
If it exists, there’s a metal of it.
Dwarf metal too
it’s all power metal with fancy lyrics
I got to see Wind Rose live last month. Amazing show!
DIGGY DIGGY HOOOOOL
DIGGY DIGGY HOOOOOL!
:D
Mithril. I like it.
Goblin metal is where it’s at
Eh… just sounds like a more screamy variant of metal. Not really my cup of tea.
Ok Mortiis, or is this Nekrogoblin?
Kill the orc slay the orc destroy the orc!
Well, I don’t like everything but that I can allow some of that, at least it is not boring.
I like metal. I don’t like discussing metal. I tell people I listen to everything, but what it literally means is I’m not offended by anything you play.
I like very specific metal and can’t even discuss metal with metal heads, because my taste is too basic, so I get you.
I just want intense music with a story.
So… Sabaton, right?
Iron Maiden, Megadeth, Black Sabbath, Testament, and some Pantera. People online shit all over them for whatever reasons. Megadeth and Pantera, I get. Lead singers are both assholes.
You might like SymphonyX - The Odyssey.
Checking back definitely love Symphony X now!! Going to check out Odyssey today.
I’m very jealous… wish I could listen to it for the first time again :)
You’re just… into heavy metal. And that’s fine. And I’m surprised you can’t discuss of those bands with fellow metalheads. In my experience, they’re often liked and held in great reverence.
Could be Gloryhammer, too
I have a friend who isn’t into metal. All his friends are into metal though, but he isn’t. So when we all talk about metal, he always brings up that one band he knows.
Sabbaton.
I’ll listen to otherwise insufferable genres if there’s a good story involved.
I get this reaction from people when playing Skinny Puppy, Igorrr, Herbie Hancock ffs… these people are sheltered, LOL!
I listen to almost anything and I recognise most of these artists.
My listening habits are “pretty much anything but country, rap/hiphop/r&b, and the extreme side of metal”. Which means I listen to classical (Chopin is the shit), most pop music, some metal, industrial, retrowave, 80/90’s, “oldies” (pre-80’s… Shout out to the playmates), etc, etc.
I also listen to some country, mainly stuff that has more substance than “truck” and “beer”. I draw the line with metal when I can’t understand the singer anymore, which, I’m sorry to my metal friends but a lot of the screaming/growling lyrical contributions fall into this category. I just don’t “get” the music so I’m not a fan.
With rap/hiphop/r&b, the same rules apply for lyrical content as country (more or less), except with the concepts of getting/being rich (and/or bragging about the things you have), and guns/crime… I guess?
Admittedly, those country/rap/hiphop/R&B exceptions still exclude a vast majority of the genres.
I’m game for pretty much anything else.
I still casually pop on some Backstreet boys, or Garth Brooks, or Eminem… Meanwhile I spend a good amount of time listening to the likes of vnv nation, Skrillex, electric cowboy, Gorillaz, 3TEETH, etc (the list is very long).
What I pick to listen to is highly dependent on my mood.
I listen to a lot of Cash. I like some country. Crosby Stills and Nash etc.
I don’t mind cash, but country isn’t a genre I dip into very often.
NOW! YOU! HAVE! SOMETHING! TO DIE FOR!!!
Goddamn I was literally just listening to them an hour ago
How very classy of you
this reminds me to check up on Slob Donovan. not that I’m exactly a fan, but it was certainly an interesting show they put on…
I’ve tried to like it. But machine-gun drums and vomiting on the mic like you have norovirus dry heaves just don’t work for me.
Yeah, blast beats are such a creative dead end… I’m getting a lot more proggy in my old age
Shhhh, just relax, take 3 hours of melodeath and it’ll all be fine when you wake up
Finna change that “everything” to, “everything with a legible logo”
Everything’s legible if you practice deciphering it enough.
party cannon it is
Some times the classics are the best.
Me: plays metal to friend Friend: “Can we, like, turn the music off and just sit in silence.”
Same friend listens to trance which just makes me fall asleep during work.
Yeah I peace out when I can’t tell if it’s the vocalist or the garbage disposal is making that noise
Death metal? Pffft, that’s mainstream swill.
<Puts on Shitnoise Bastards> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIpJ5Xl0PR4
