I now have a full time job plus a long commute, which means… more time for reading manga while half-asleep? Huh?
Anyway the last thread of this kind was in July, and since then an anime season has finished, so might as well do it again.
For me:
Manga:
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (2005): Parallel to watching the excellent adaptation, I have picked up the manga and, much like Kaiji, finished it in a concerningly short time. Koji Kumeta has a bone to pick with the world… with everything in the world. What arises is a very entertaining ruthless critique. I’m fairly sure he’s either still a leftist, or used to be one and got disappointed. However, he is also nationalistic. A political mess, mostly agreeable, sometimes dropping horrible takes - but a fantastic manga which never loses its bite no matter how many chapters you are into it. It’s also less horny than the Shaft adaptation. A+
√Paradise (1991): Being curious about Kumeta’s early work, I read this short manga of his, which is basically the Yakuza games’ cabaret club side-plot in manga form. Not too interesting, but a decent enough read. B-
Ijiranaide, Nagatoro-san (2017): Nagatoro is a decent romance manga with a pretty bad beginning. It ended a few months ago, but I have caught up only recently. Not much else to say, really. B
Shiroyama to Mita-san (2021): Nice comedic romance/slice of life manga about two (mostly) uncool people. Fun, but have not finished it yet. B+
Anime:
Aa-Megami Sama (2005): I had read a large chunk of the manga before, and it’s just as fun as I remembered it being. The romance stuff isn’t too strong, but the hijinks are fun. The source material being from the 80s means that many of the usual tropes didn’t exist yet… or were being invented. A-
Fullmetal Alchemist (2003): Almost done with this show, it’s been really good overall. Strong characters and storytelling, and the anime original plot… I can clearly see why it’s controversial, but I like it. Good show. A
Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines! (2024): The only seasonal I didn’t drop. Story-wise very conventional, but the character writing was good. Anna Yanami in particular, being one of the strongest female leads in recent anime history. It had a few tone-unfitting scenes that felt tacked on for the horny audience, but overall decent show. B
Western Animation
The Owl House (2020): Very fun show, with some blatant inspiration from many recognizable source materials, western and Japanese. King is a king. A
I had to stop reading manga because my tablet died so I have been unable to continue most of my reads. I have been trying chinese mangha (is the name correct?) and I have been enjoying it more since I’m kind of tired of manga tropes. Regarding anime, with the end of the season and the start of the new one, there is not much to talk about yet. I also got a bit burned out from anime in general so I have not watched as much as I usually do. Some highlights from the old season are:
Dead Demons Dededede Destruction - Amazing show. Engaging in every moment from the beginning to almost the end. Great characters and subtle societal comentary about migration and liberalism. Didn’t really like the ending tho. I understand why it went that way but it felt more like a cop out than a proper resolution. I haven’t read the manga yet so it might be a presentation problem (why does ep 0 even exist???).
Oshi no Ko 2 - Adaptation of my least liked (debatible) arc from the manga and I enjoyed even then. The anime art decisions were really good and make it more engaging than I can remember feeling when reading the manga. Story is still a mess and I can complain about it a lot but at least it was fun. Also, I was getting very tired of this last manga arc so I’m not really missing it but I have heard good opinions of the last episodes so I might try to start reading again soon
Senpai wa Otokonoko - I really liked the start but I slowly started disliking most things about it. I am aware that expecting good queer representation in anime is hard but even then I got disapointed. Worst part is that I read the manga a couple of years ago and was disapointed even then. I really need to start handling my expectations better.
Old anime I’m watching:
Rockman.EXE - It’s a kids anime but it has something that is hard to replicate. The vision of the internet in that era was really fun and interesting. It reminds me a lot about Digimon. I’m enjoying this alot but thinking that it has 5 seasons of ~50 episodes is making me wonder where am I going to stop.
ODDTAXI - Rewatched it recently to watch the live action spinnoff and it’s amazing how good it is. Characters are great and their whole interaction is wacky and weird but very enjoyable. Spinoff is simply bad so no comments.
Movies:
Blue Giant - Simple story but amazing concert animations and incredible music. It was probably one of the best animated experiences I have ever had and I loved every single second of it. For whoever enjoys jazz, this is something I would completely recommend
Blue Giant - Simple story but amazing concert animations and incredible music. It was probably one of the best animated experiences I have ever had and I loved every single second of it. For whoever enjoys jazz, this is something I would completely recommend
Ughhhhh, I need to get around to this and Kids on the Slope
I’m 6 episodes into Make Heroine ga Oosugiru!(makeine) and its quite a good surprise in every way. At this rate it is definitely one of the best of the year. Surprisngly top tier production and it doesn’t feel like it was wasted on “just another light novel”.
This month:
Last Exile: WW1 aesthetics, but taking place entirely in flying ships. Tons of passable CGI with very ok dogfights. It’s pretty average, but you do get one of the leads as Haruko from FLCL. I’ve had this one on my to watch list for over a decade, so I’m pretty disappointed that it turned out to be passable at best.
Oshi No Ko S2: I’m also disappointed with this one, but for a different reason. The first episode (movie?) of the first season was absolutely stellar. Psychological thriller par excellance. It seems to just be a harem with pretty animation now, I guess? I feel like it has all the potential to be something great, but it misses so many layups that I might just drop it considering what is supposed to be coming in the manga. I’m particularly irked with Kana being written to fawn over the main character, when she has the depth to be more than that.
I’m looking forward to starting Dan Da Dan sometime soon considering the studio behind it.
WHY DID NOBODY REMIND ME THAT UZUMAKI IS OUT!
The animation was well worth the wait, but I wish the dub was different somehow. I tried the subbed version but it still has the same “animeness” problem. It’s hard to put it into words, but I think the overacting doesn’t suit the show well. However, even by the second episode I’m either getting more into it or the show itself is getting better. Junji Ito’s work is notoriously difficult to adapt, and I think this anime is doing pretty good. The animation is absolutely fantastic, black and white was the right choice and the occasional rotoscoping is downright creepy just as it should be. I think most of my dissatisfaction with the voicework is down to it not measuring up to what’s in my head- there’s a reason Bill Watterson refuses to license Calvin and Hobbes, for example.
I also decided to try out Kimi wa Meido-sama because I like wish-fulfillment trash and was willing to give it a go. I was surprised at just how good the animation was and the opening was a fantastic mismatch of animation styles. It has a lot of cliches (maid! subservient waifu! highschool protagonist living on his own for no reason! obvious Yor knockoff!) etc but the animation was really good and Meido-sama had the cutest little chibi sad dog face I’ve ever seen that I finished the episode. Time will tell if I continue to watch this well-made trash.
I watched Fukuyama Gekijou Natsu no Himitsu yesterday off of a Hazel recommendation from her recent video. All I could find was an unsubbed Youtube video. Fuck copyright and RIP Aniwave. If anyone can find a subbed version of this cute little show I can stream let me know.
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
There’s a torrent up on nyaa.si that looks to have subs, haven’t confirmed myself though.
I am mainly watching my watchlist at the moment, since I already finished all good anime ever released. So now I just stare at the list of anime I could maybe watch, alongside the list of anime that would be a total waste to watch if I’m not in the right mood for them (I never am).
Dragon ball super: its to formative to my childhood to rate fairly
Haven’t been watching/reading much.
Working thru:
Anime:
Oshi No Ko season 2 is good, but I’ve been reading the manga, so I’m not rushed.
Shikanoko is alright, though in small doses. I’m like 5 or 6 episodes in? It is sadly not kino at the level of Zetsubou Sensei (glad others are experiencing the greatness!)
Western Animation
I am once again asking you to watch Over the Garden Wall. Trying to savor it this year, so I’m only on episode 2/10 of my rewatch
Thanks to you I remember that I already have downloaded Aa-megami Sama and Sayonara Zetsubo sensei but never actually watched them. Ooops. Maybe i’ll give them a try. Ah, and shiroyama to mita-san seems interesting. Thanks!
I’m still stuck on Deer Friend Nokotan and the Suicide Squad anime. Both are okay, nothing too special. I’m going to cut back in the future on watching stuff that doesn’t blow me away. I will say Nokotan is quite cute and random which I do like.
I just don’t have the time to watch stuff that’s only okay these days.
Yeah, same. Dropped the two of them basically instantly. I expected way more from nokotan.
If you want a comedy anime that delivers. You HAVE to try Nichijou
I did! Abolutely amazing :)
Happy to hear you enjoyed it. It’s a real shame we only got one season of that.
Yeah, but now they’re working on ‘City The Animation’! Seems like it’ll be a nichijou v2
Anime
- Ghost in the Shell SAC S2 This shit sucks and I’ve totally stalled on it for months with like 10 eps left due to the non-stop copaganda (does it even count as copaganda if they’re mercenaries?). I WILL finish it eventually. Apparently everyone says S1 is better but I think they’re roughly comparable which is to say equally bad. Perhaps this is a thing of it being the first in the genre which means that I’ve seen other media that more thoroughly explored the ideas, but honestly none of this seems groundbreaking.
- The Girl Who Leapt Through Time A clear case of working backwards from a cool concept resulting in a weak story. Imo the first half of “fuckin’ around with time travel” is fun but the back half of drama/romance is boring.
- Castle in the Sky It’s fine. A kids movie that’s pretty solid. Watching it the main thing I noticed was just how different the types of conflict and sense of adventure were from most modern stuff I watch. I wish that they gave an example of… who the CIA wanted to actually go to war with? Perhaps that’s the point, that geopolitics is so removed from the average person’s life that they aren’t even aware of it, but I definitely lean more towards a “this is for kids” explanation.
- Dead Dead Demon’s Dededede Destruction About 2/3 through, pretty solid but weird. Very anti-american, which you love to see, and also critical of japanese nationalism. The art style is very different from typical cutesy anime characters, with all of the main girls being disproportioned blobs. Probably helps stuff like the student-teacher “romance” come off less creepy. Oran needs to read theory.
- Oshi no Ko The only seasonal I’m watching, a solid season that’s very character-driven with not much happening with the main plot. Last episode in 2 days I think, and I’m looking forward to it. Ruby needs to learn basic math.
Manga
- Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint The sloppiest of korean slop. What if the superpower of the main character was that he read too many webnovels? There’re some fun character intereaction bits, but the action scenes are mostly unreadable garbage, and as seems to be the way in this subgenre of power fantasy, at some point the power-scaling gets so out there that the numbers cease to mean anything.
- Chainsaw Man and One Piece Still keeping up. CSM continues to be good.
What would you recommend instead of GITS? I’ve always had a soft spot for it considering it was my first “adult” anime.
Depends what you’re looking for.
- For cyberpunk action, Cyberpunk: Edgerunners is the obvious recommendation. Akudama Drive might also fit the bill, or Vivy: Fluorite Eyes’ Song (I wasn’t a huge fan it but the central premise is “legally distinct Hatsune Miku must time travel to stop the robot apocalypse”).
- For something with thoughtful politics, sadly I don’t think I’ve ever watched an anime that I’d say is actually good on this front. The best is probably Legend of the Galactic Heroes, but that’s a very different genre. Planetes, maybe; it’s also technically sci-fi but it’s very grounded and a totally different genre. Both of these are unfortunately still Weird About Women (but so is every anime so…).
I get the feeling that a lot of philosophical musings don’t translate well because I can’t recall an anime that made me really think but that could just be me.
I was never really a big fan of GITS for its action sequences, but they are a nice touch. I think you’re right in your second point. The only anime that comes to mind in that milieu would be Kaiba (Kino’s Journey too, but that’s a totally different premise).
I have a few shows I’m working through rn: Bungo Stray Dogs (finally at s5), The Many Sides of Voice Actor Radio (almost done), My Deer Friend Nokotan (taking my time because it’s fantastic), rewatching D-Frag on my own, Re:Zero
I feel like I’m forgetting something
The Fable just finished airing, and I enjoyed it quite a bit.
Oh yeah, directed by Ryosuke Takahashi (of VOTOMS, etc. fame). I still need to check it out.
PTSD never looked so elegant. (Area 88)
The 90’s fashion in ah my goddess,
Indeed