- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
edit: As I’m seeing a lot of worry about the impact this will/could have on the community, please be assured we have the same mod team, and will be holding the community to the same standards. the same things that were always allowed will continue to be allowed and the same things that got things removed before will continue to get things removed before. Lemmy.world admins have agreed to allow us to run our community on our terms.
It is my pleasure to announce that effective immediately, we are transferring our community to Lemmy.world! This has been a few months in the making, so my entire mod team is already on board.
FAQ:
Why?
That’s a complicated question with a long answer! The primary difference is moderatorial and ideologial differences between my team and Ada’s excellent team of admins. We are on good terms with Ada and her team, and have gotten her consent to do this. In addition to this, we have had ongoing issues with federation and moderation that has caused a subpar experience for many people on other instances.
How does this work?
Currently, as there is not an easy way to transfer an entire community (trust me, we checked), we are locking the community as mod-only, and moving our focus to the 196 on lemmy.world. For you guys, functionally nothing has changed.
What about the posts?
Well, we tried to transfer them, but there was no real way to do so without absolutely destroying lemmy.world’s federation. For this reason, we are simply archiving this community as mod-only. Everything is staying up, you just won’t be able to post new content. Comments are still enabled, so we will continue to check our modlogs for some time after the transfer has settled.
As for the posts on lemmy.world’s 196, we’re leaving those up too. From this point onwards, all posts made to that community are beholden to the rules you are all used to, but anything pre-existing is getting grandfathered in.
IF YOU GUYS HAVE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, PLEASE PUT THEM IN THE COMMENTS OF THIS POST, AND I’LL DO MY BEST TO ANSWER THEM.
Once again, here’s the link to our new apartment of awesome. (universal: [email protected])
agh idk dog… the comment sections of lemmy.world are a bit of a cesspool. I’ll miss the pro-trans good vibes
Moving out of LBZ doesn’t mean we’re not a pro-trans community anymore. As far as moderation goes, nothing is changing. If we see an influx of transphobes or bad actors, we’ll do the same thing we’ve always done and simply ban them.
As far as moderation goes, nothing is changing.
How are we supposed to square this with the rationale for the break being to get away from stricter moderating?
I’m saying our moderation isn’t changing. Like, the rules page is word for word the same as it was in LBZ. We’re still not tolerating MAGA shit, transphobes, tankie shit, etc.
This raises the question: is it your moderation that people like? Or do people only like it as much because of the extra layer of moderation you dislike?
Strong agree. Can’t speak for anyone else, but here’s me a few months ago thanking Ada specifically for this reason.
Just create a new one
Dotworld’s admins just brought in a policy that specifically requires mods to be permissive of a certain degree of concern trolling and/or sealioning. Can you be sure you’ll be able to moderate the community to the satisfaction of its existing userbase?
we have been given a large degree of freedom in how we run our community by lemmy.world admins, with an aggrement that we would be able to continue to moderate our community by our rules. I can guarantee we will not be expected to entertain trolls, as I ensured we would not have to before approving the transfer.
I can guarantee we will not be expected to entertain trolls
I’m so glad for you to explicitly spell this out for us. Really, it was obvious but im glad you’re not hiding
I’m pretty sure we can, and they rescinded the policy anyways. I think they mainly wanted to combat censorship, so I think whatever they update it to will be reasonable.
The kind of content they were concerned about was respectful and well-meaning people, so I’m confident that if we continue to ban/remove people/comments as we have been doing, there will be no problems.
Well, good luck. I mean it. I just wish this didn’t mean that the existing community gets locked down.
I would like to propose a solution that I think can make everyone happy. Transfer ownership of Blahaj 196 to a new mod team and make World 196 the alternate community. If anyone wishes to follow the original mod team into world they would be able to, meanwhile blahaj 196 would follow the values of Blahaj. I personally volunteer to either be the head or a moderator here.
The primary difference is moderatorial and ideologial differences between my team and Ada’s excellent team of admins
Can you expand on this? It’s not really clear to me why you’re making this move.
Basically it’s “vibes”, that’s the only explanation the 196 mods intend to give us
see here: https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/post/20937206/12464713
looks like the main “ideological” differences are about what counts as violations and how to deal with them:
a 196 mod said:
sometimes we’ll see people getting banned or comments getting removed for relatively mild takes. We also often disagreed about the severity of the actions, like ban lengths being way too long considering the reason, or people getting banned over something that really should just be a removal.
part of Ada’s response:
every post and user I removed was due to queerphobia, transphobia, trolling or spam, issues that broke the instances rules. Some of that bigotry was was implicit rather than explicit, like dog whistles, tone policing etc. Some of it was the “just asking questions” transphobia that pervades most corporate owned social media spaces. … As moss said, this is ideological differences in how low grade transphobia and queerphobia should be dealt with. moss is ok with community pushback for the low grade stuff rather than moderation, whereas I’ll just remove it.
They could still transfer the existing community
Sorry can you say more? I am not connecting the dots between my comment and yours. I am only trying to answer blackn1ght’s question about what the ideological differences were between 196 mods and the Blahaj admins.
While there are differences in moderation styles as you detailed in your post, that does not explain why they couldn’t just leave the Blahaj community open, potentially to Blahaj admins who would call for a new mod team rather than locking it down.
Not sure I need you to keep copying the comments in both places, but to respond here as well, yes - I agree.
Sounds good!
That why doesn’t really answer much. Are we making 196 a safe space for transphobia or something?
Absolutely not. Our rules aren’t changing and neither is the mod team. Our top priority is, and always will be, cultivating a community where queer people of all flavors feel welcome and safe.
You should know thst somewhat recently .world was in hot water because their admins have told their mods that they (the mods) are going to have to engage trolls in good faith. The statements were about forcing their mods to allow some “flat earth” comments to stay, to be unable to ban things like that.
Fuck this. I’ll be blocking the
newfake 196 then.Every single post on the “new” community is from a .world user. Maybe its time for me to block all of .world, it was pretty clear from the start that .world is predatory but this just makes me even more sure. They can have fun over there with their meta/threads federation lol
:(
.world is federating with threads?? eww
Yes
Time to make /196part two on Blahaj I guess.
deleted by creator
One day should be enough, members should act when there’s still momentum
Good point.
You people should just get back the original one
or we could get new moderators to ask for control of this comm
Even better.
We won’t be moving to world with you. We like blahaj and we like 196 being on blahaj. If you don’t want to be here, you should instead just hand over your mod positions to people who do.
Absolutely foul decision. From the recent discussions i think it was very clear that the actual regular users and posters of 196 were opposed to moving to .world. What a clown show of a mod team.
Yeah, exactly, what the fuck?
Bad move :(
Lame move. The .world instance has been getting worse for a long while. Why not go elsewhere if it’s really that important? 196 is one of the most active communities I’ve seen so the de-federation issue doesn’t sound like one.
care to elaborate on this “worsening” ?
https://lemmy.world/c/lemmyworld
You can just browse through their announcements and see for yourself. I admire their dedication and how they’ve managed to accept us Reddit refugees but they keep making these strange missteps in their administration.
I personally wouldn’t make a community in their instance as I don’t trust the admins. They also don’t mind de-federating other instances; see dbz0 (I can never remember the name right).
The first one looks like they’re dealing with code of inconsistent quality from Lemmy developers, but the second one is weird. Everything is all crossed out.
it was crossed out because it was rescinded. it was rescinded because it was a bad decision.
I thought they’d but put some non crossed out text explaining this, but they crossed everything out.
deleted by creator
Good point, I even forgot about that
I think I sort of understand what they meant when they talked about narratives, although I interpret it as being extremely naïve. Sure, it’s true that people often only defend one narrative because it’s the only one they know, and haven’t been exposed to other ones (or at least in a way where they actually thought critically about it and haven’t just refuted the “new” perspective on first sight). But it’s extremely unrealistic to think that people will change their opinion due to a couple of comments on the Internet (specially when people have joked for years that disscussions on the Internet never go anywhere). Not just that, but by saying that you want people to be able to voice other narratives and not specifying if those include things like hate speech (even if you thought of not including those), you’re scaring the shit out of marginalized communities that use the platform, which get a lot of hate every day and just want places in the Internet where they can chill and not have to worry about that sort of stuff. I honestly think that there is a misunderstanding of what the admins meant with that, I think that they don’t really intend to endanger their marginalized users (although I could just be interpreting this wrongly, you never know)… But even if they wanted to, it wouldn’t really matter for us, as it would just make the job harder for the 196 mods, who, expectably, will keep on moderating as they always did, keeping TERFs, homophobes and other haters away from this lovely community (, right? riiiiiight???).
…and I would just say this if LW admins weren’t so open to federating with Meta products. Even if we ignore how shitty Meta is as a company, federating with them would bring very little advantages to the table (like, idk, being able to follow some friends and family, and some famous people, and talking with them to some capacity without a Meta account, but still having to follow Meta’s ToS obviously), but lots of disadvantages instead (not much more adhesion to the Fediverse because people will keep on using Meta’s products anyways; possible “embrace, extend, extinguish” from Meta, which could really damage the Fediverse; Meta possibly involving themselves in some of the Fediverse projects, which could result in them “steering the wheel” as they see fit; and most importantly, spreading the Fediverse’s moderation resources thin, due to a way larger influx of users and Meta’s shitty moderation). I’m not mad by people who want to federate with Meta, as it sounds really cool to federate with a bunch more people and present to them the wonderful world of the Fediverse. I’m just a bit let down because those people won’t realize that things will barely be as cool as they sound once they try federating with Meta.
WHY ARE U MOVING INSTANCE?
A single drawn out argument over a not even that controversial mod decision. Very sad that the blahaj admins allowed this mod to fuck over this whole community for no good reason and against the will of basically the entirety of this community.
if i could downvote, i would! >>>>>>:((((((((
this is a VERY UNCOMFY move!!! >>>>:((((
just to make it obvious, these are ANGRY FACES!!!
(im saying this cuz maybe 196 mods or whatever cannot understand these kinds of emotions)“>” are the ANGRY EYEBROWS! “:” are the EYES and “(” is the SAD MOUTH!!!
I AM VERY SAD! i will NOT lurk on ur evil .world “replacement”.
this is NOT what the FEDIVERSE IS MEANT TO BE!!!
the fediverse is meant to be DECENTRALIZED!!! across MULTIPLE INSTANCES!
this is NOT a “very fediverse move” you are doing here. This is a “reddit move”!
im gonna say it. this is straight up u/spez stuff happening here.
i HOPE that my comment gets blocked or removed by my instance maintainers, so that it becomes OBVIOUS that such hatespeech, which is allowed on .world is NOT OKAY!
(yes i mean my hatespeech rn, im in evil mode today, this is very evil, i dun like this at all. will not support this evil behavior)
sorry for anticlimacting the angry mood but the angry faces made me want to hug u >v<
It’s weird - you and I have never interacted, and we’re usually engaging in totally different discussions in the fediverse, but every time I see a post from you my first thought is “We must protect Smorty at all costs. If Smorty stops posting, the fediverse has lost its way.”
#makesmortyhappyagain
Bye then, I won’t be following
For the love of god, leave this community here and just create a new mod team instead. This community being on Blåhaj specifically is a big plus for a lot of us
Honestly on board with this. 196 took up more of Blahaj than I liked and always had a weirdly dissonant feel to the rest of the instance. I’m not really a fan of 196 personally, though, so my opinion is colored by that.
I did feel like we grew a little bit bigger than made sense on blahaj.zone. the instance feed was 90% our community and I could absolutely see that suffocating smaller ones trying to get started here.